Rethinking Causality, Complexity and Evidence for the Unique Patient : A CauseHealth Resource for Healthcare Professionals and the Clinical Encounter.
Main Author: | |
---|---|
Other Authors: | , |
Format: | eBook |
Language: | English |
Published: |
Cham :
Springer International Publishing AG,
2020.
|
Edition: | 1st ed. |
Subjects: | |
Online Access: | Click to View |
Table of Contents:
- Rethinking Causality, Complexity and Evidence for the Unique Patient
- Preface
- The Story of CauseHealth
- Reference
- Abbreviations
- Contents
- List of Figures
- Contributors to Part II
- Editors and Contributors to Part I
- Notes on Editors and Contributors
- Part I: Philosophical Framework
- Chapter 1: Introduction: Why Is Philosophy Relevant for Clinical Practice?
- Chapter 2: Dispositions and the Unique Patient
- 2.1 The Similar and the Unique
- 2.2 Empiricism: Causality Requires Repeated Observations
- 2.3 Dispositionalism: Causality Happens in the Single Case
- 2.3.1 Causes Are Dispositions
- 2.3.2 Causes Are Intrinsic
- 2.3.3 Causality Is Complex
- 2.3.4 Causality Is Context-Sensitive
- 2.3.5 Modelling Causality
- 2.3.6 Two Types of Causal Interference
- 2.3.7 Degree of Tendency
- 2.3.8 Threshold Effects and Tipping Points
- 2.4 Philosophy of Causality Influences Scientific Methods
- 2.5 Practical Implications for the Clinic
- 2.5.1 Causal Evidence Comes from the Patient
- 2.5.2 There Is No Standard or Average Patient
- 2.5.3 Unexpected Outcomes Are Valuable Causal Lessons
- 2.6 To Sum Up…
- References and Further Readings
- Chapter 3: Probability for the Clinical Encounter
- 3.1 Uncertainty and Probability in the Single Case
- 3.2 Probability from Statistics: Frequentism
- 3.2.1 Frequentism and Evidence Based Approaches
- 3.2.2 Randomisation, Inclusion Criteria and Exclusion Criteria in Population Trials
- 3.2.3 Internal and External Validity of Causal Claims from Randomised Controlled Trials
- 3.3 Probability as Degree of Belief: Subjective Credence
- 3.3.1 Updating Belief
- 3.3.2 Understanding the Basic Bayesian Formula
- 3.3.3 Uncertainty as Lack of Knowledge
- 3.4 Probabilities as Dispositional and Intrinsic: Propensities.
- 3.4.1 Individual Propensities Are Not Always Seen Through Frequencies
- 3.4.2 Propensities as Qualities
- 3.4.3 Propensities and Prediction
- 3.5 Propensities and the Clinic
- 3.5.1 The Importance of Local Knowledge
- 3.5.2 Person Centered Clinical Analysis
- 3.5.3 Focus on Theories of Causal Mechanism
- 3.5.4 Multidisciplinarity and Networking
- 3.5.5 The Potential of Clinical Experience for Advancing Medical Knowledge
- 3.5.6 What Does N = 1 Mean, Within the CauseHealth Project?
- 3.6 To Sum Up…
- References and Further Readings
- Chapter 4: When a Cause Cannot Be Found
- 4.1 The Clinical Challenge of Medically Unexplained Symptoms (MUS)
- 4.2 The Problem of Uniqueness
- 4.2.1 The Patient Context: What Was There Before
- 4.2.2 Qualitative and Quantitative Approaches to Causal Inquiry
- 4.2.3 Dispositional Take On Perfect Regularity: Is It Causality or Something Else Entirely?
- 4.3 An Important Lesson from Medically Unexplained Symptoms (MUS)
- 4.3.1 We Need Many Methods to Establish Causality
- 4.4 Patient Narratives as a Way Forward
- 4.5 Using Patient Narratives
- 4.5.1 Narrative as a Tool for Causality Assessment
- 4.5.2 Narrative as a Tool for Understanding the Causal Story
- 4.5.3 Narrative as a Collaborative Tool in Healthcare
- 4.6 To Sum Up…
- References
- Chapter 5: Complexity, Reductionism and the Biomedical Model
- 5.1 The Biomedical Model of Illness
- 5.1.1 Reductionism in Medicine and Science
- 5.1.2 Critical Reflections Concerning the Biomedical Model
- 5.2 The Bio-psychosocial Model of Illness
- 5.2.1 Bottom Up and Top Down Causality in Medical Research: Two Views on Cancer Aetiology
- 5.3 The CauseHealth Approach: Change Must Start from Ontology
- 5.4 What Is Causal Complexity and How Should It Be Investigated?
- 5.4.1 Mereological Composition
- 5.4.2 Genuine Complexity and Emergence.
- 5.4.3 Practice Is Motivated by Ontological Bias
- 5.5 We Need an Ecological Turn in Medicine and Healthcare
- 5.5.1 Whole Person Healthcare in Practice
- 5.6 To Sum Up…
- References and Further Readings
- Chapter 6: The Guidelines Challenge
- 6.1 The Tension Within
- 6.1.1 Evidence Based Medicine and the Rise of Guidelines
- 6.1.2 Guidelines in Practice
- 6.2 Guidelines and Tramlines
- 6.2.1 Guidelines and Evidence Based Policy
- 6.3 The Ontology of Guidelines
- 6.3.1 Logically Speaking, Guidelines Cannot Be Rules
- 6.3.2 What Does This Mean for Guidelines in Practice?
- 6.4 The Epistemology of Guidelines
- 6.4.1 Transparency and the Tension Between Flexibility and Standardization
- 6.4.2 When Should the Particular Be Engaged?
- 6.5 Guidelines in the Dispositionalist Way
- 6.5.1 So, What Should We Do with Guidelines?
- 6.6 To Sum Up…
- References and Further Readings
- Part II: Application to the Clinic
- Chapter 7: The Complexity of Persistent Pain - A Patient's Perspective
- 7.1 Introduction
- 7.2 The Injury I Haven't Recovered From
- 7.3 Being Treated Within a Narrow View of Pain
- 7.4 Starting to Learn About the Complexity of Pain
- 7.5 Learning About Causality and Dispositionalism
- 7.6 A Smallholding Analogy
- 7.7 The Analogy Explained
- 7.8 Combining Causality, Dispositionalism and Predictive Processing
- 7.9 A Simple Understanding of My Pain
- 7.10 How Has Understanding Pain in This Way Helped Me?
- 7.11 The Complexity of Persistent Pain
- Chapter 8: Above and Beyond Statistical Evidence. Why Stories Matter for Clinical Decisions and Shared Decision Making
- 8.1 Musculoskeletal Disability
- 8.2 Evidence Based Healthcare: The Heart Is in the Right Place, But…
- 8.3 Therapeutic Alliance: A Dispositional View
- 8.4 Bringing the Totality of Evidence Together
- References and Further Readings.
- Chapter 9: Causality and Dispositionality in Medical Practice
- 9.1 Some Background
- 9.2 Considering Causality
- 9.3 Diagnosis and Decisions
- 9.4 Overview of Important Dispositional Insights in Clinical Care
- 9.5 Conclusion
- References and Further Readings
- Chapter 10: Lessons on Causality from Clinical Encounters with Severely Obese Patients
- 10.1 Introduction
- 10.2 A Framework for the Clinical Encounter
- 10.2.1 The Person in the Role of the Patient - What Are the Goals of Healthcare?
- 10.2.2 A Group Seminar Before the Clinical Encounter: Setting the Stage
- 10.2.3 The Consultant's Understanding in Advance of the Clinical Encounter
- 10.2.4 The Clinical Encounter
- 10.2.5 As a Child, Did You Feel Safe at Home?
- 10.2.6 The Consultant's and Patient's Understanding After the Clinical Encounter
- 10.3 Case Stories
- 10.3.1 Olav Olsen, a Severely Obese Man
- 10.3.2 Alma Almas, a Severely Obese Woman
- 10.3.3 Ebba Eskil, a Severely Obese and Depressed Woman
- 10.4 Where Do We Go from Here?
- 10.4.1 "What the Hell Is Going on Here?"
- 10.4.2 Is This How the System Works?
- 10.5 Outlook
- References and Further Readings
- Chapter 11: Reflections on the Clinician's Role in the Clinical Encounter
- 11.1 Introduction
- 11.2 Reflections on How Values Affect Clinical Encounters
- 11.3 The Work I Did with Marie
- 11.3.1 Presentation of the Client
- 11.3.2 Presenting Problems
- 11.3.3 Diagnosis
- 11.3.4 The I-Thou Process
- 11.3.5 Key Episode 1
- 11.3.6 Key Episode 2
- 11.4 Reflections
- References and Further Readings
- Chapter 12: The Relevance of Dispositionalism for Psychotherapy and Psychotherapy Research
- 12.1 Introductory Preface
- 12.2 Misleading Statement on Evidence Based Psychological Practice
- 12.3 Questioning the Medical Model
- 12.4 The Challenge from Dodo-Birds and Meaning-Makers.
- 12.5 The Philosophical Bias of the Medical Model
- 12.6 Dodo-Birds Must Take the Bull by Its Horns
- 12.7 Meaning-Makers Must Target the Right Enemy
- 12.8 Humeanism Must Be Replaced by Dispositionalism
- 12.9 Implications for Psychotherapy Research
- 12.10 Implications for Psychotherapy
- 12.11 As Statistics Don't Get It, Try Getting the Vectors Right
- References and Further Readings
- Chapter 13: Causal Dispositionalism and Evidence Based Healthcare
- 13.1 Complexity in Practice
- 13.2 Evidential Hierarchies Expose Causal Theory
- 13.3 A Dispositionalist Response
- 13.3.1 Explain the Causal Role of Content from Particular Research Methods
- 13.3.2 Motivate a Viable Epistemology
- 13.3.3 Account for Causal Processes in Individual Level Clinical Decision Making
- 13.3.4 Help Understand and Assess Additional Premises and Assumptions Needed to Bridge the Inferential Gap Between Population Level Evidence and Clinical Decisions
- 13.4 Conclusion
- References and Further Readings
- Chapter 14: The Practice of Whole Person-Centred Healthcare
- 14.1 A Woman with Skin Disease
- 14.2 A Professional Evolution
- 14.3 Somatic Metaphors
- 14.4 Whole Persons in the Clinic
- 14.5 Reactions from Colleagues
- 14.6 Dualist Psychotherapy
- 14.7 Publications
- 14.8 Human Infant Development
- 14.9 Mindbody Healthcare
- 14.10 I Was Conflicted
- 14.11 Being Looked at or Being Seen?
- References and Further Readings
- Chapter 15: A Broken Child - A Diseased Woman
- 15.1 Cecily Cramer
- 15.2 Crisis Onset
- 15.3 Two In-Patient Psychiatric Hospital Ward Admissions
- 15.4 Follow-Up Care
- 15.5 Reflections
- 15.5.1 Recently Acquired Knowledge
- 15.5.2 Updating the Concept of Causality
- References and Further Readings
- Chapter 16: Conclusion: CauseHealth Recommendations for Making Causal Evidence Clinically Relevant and Informed.
- 16.1 Practical Recommendations for Change.